The 2025 NFL Season, Graded
Seattle Seahawks won it all. The people predicting football went 50.9 for 100.
The Seattle Seahawks (14–3) won the Super Bowl over the New England Patriots (14–3). Along the way, 106 pundits made 1,699 claims specific enough to grade against it.
- Super Bowl champions
- SEA
- Takes graded
- 1,699
- Pundits on the record
- 106
- Average accuracy
- 50.9
against 2025 results
out of 100
What was hard to call in 2025
Average score by kind of claim, ten graded minimum — the shape of the season's difficulty.
- Pro Bowl and All-Pro Calls10 graded0.0
- Coach Award Picks14 graded7.1
- Award Picks44 graded18.2
- Player Season Numbers41 graded25.8
- Super Bowl Picks46 graded30.4
- Positional Finishes127 graded32.6
- Mock Draft Picks641 graded48.7
- Sleeper Calls12 graded50.0
- Top Player Lists27 graded50.2
- Playoff Picks135 graded51.9
- Season Win Totals117 graded54.0
- Game Outcome Picks253 graded55.7
- Score Predictions42 graded63.3
- Power Rankings32 graded65.0
- Fantasy Rankings18 graded65.4
- Position Order Calls13 graded72.9
- Depth Chart Calls111 graded93.7
Pundit-seasons of 2025
Best skill against a naive guess on the same claims, ten graded calls minimum in the season.
| Pundit | Graded | Accuracy | Skill |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peter Schrager | 13 | 73.6 | +40.0 |
| Kyle Crabbs | 323 | 38.0 | +37.4 |
| Bucky Brooks | 47 | 60.3 | +32.3 |
| Daniel Jeremiah | 72 | 57.8 | +27.5 |
| Derek Brown | 21 | 46.2 | +25.1 |
| Scott Bogman | 12 | 24.7 | +25.0 |
| Steve Mensch | 14 | 37.0 | +24.3 |
| Jason McIntyre | 21 | 65.7 | +23.6 |