NFL top player lists

Graded under the published methodology. Each call shows what it scored and how much better than a naive guess that was. How this kind is scored →

Takes logged: 377
Graded: 104
Average accuracy: 54.7
Pundits: 130

How these land

Every graded call of this kind, by score.

Takes in each band

14

1

4

7

12

13

18

15

9

11

20 scored 80+26 under 40

Settled or waiting

104 / 377

graded

273 still pending

Who is good at this

MissedTakes score for this kind only. Zero means no better than guessing.

Jason Cabinda100 accuracy · 1 graded+100.0
Danny G100 accuracy · 1 graded+100.0
Mike Mayock

By publisher

Overreaction Monday (podcast)68.8 · 1 graded
The 33rd Team72.2 · 30 graded

Every NFL top player lists take

1–25 of 377

0

20

40

60

80

0 — dead wrongscore out of 100100 — nailed it

95 accuracy · 1 graded

+90.0

Daniel Jeremiah84 accuracy · 2 graded+68.8

Matt Harmon80 accuracy · 2 graded+60.2

Kyle Crabbs74 accuracy · 2 graded+48.5

Dan Pizzuta80 accuracy · 3 graded+44.6

Robert Smith83 accuracy · 1 graded+33.0

Marcus Mosher83 accuracy · 2 graded+32.9

Jason McIntyre75 accuracy · 1 graded+25.0

Bucky Brooks73 accuracy · 1 graded+23.0

Charles McDonald61 accuracy · 1 graded+22.4

Nick Wright58 accuracy · 4 graded+20.8

Jordan Vanek63 accuracy · 1 graded+19.8

Peter Schrager64 accuracy · 3 graded+19.4

Patrick Claybon58 accuracy · 2 graded+15.2

Chad Millman57 accuracy · 1 graded+13.7

Logan Ryan56 accuracy · 1 graded+11.9

Connor Livesay60 accuracy · 1 graded+10.0

Simon Hunter55 accuracy · 1 graded+9.9

Kevin Riley55 accuracy · 1 graded+7.0

John Middlekauff43 accuracy · 2 graded+5.0

Jeremy Fowler52 accuracy · 2 graded+4.2

Gregg Rosenthal55 accuracy · 6 graded+3.2

Kyle Brandt60 accuracy · 5 graded+0.0

Manti Te'o50 accuracy · 1 graded+0.0

Danny Parkins48 accuracy · 2 graded-4.2

Rich Eisen45 accuracy · 5 graded-7.9

Colin Cowherd49 accuracy · 5 graded-9.1

ESPN44 accuracy · 1 graded-11.5

Rich Riebar43 accuracy · 1 graded-13.9

Chad Ochocinco Johnson43 accuracy · 2 graded-15.0

Chris Simms40 accuracy · 1 graded-20.0

Nick Shook30 accuracy · 2 graded-20.5

Dan Patrick20 accuracy · 2 graded-30.0

Justin Penik15 accuracy · 2 graded-35.0

Shannon Sharpe25 accuracy · 2 graded-35.4

Isaiah Stanback28 accuracy · 2 graded-45.0

Jamie Erdahl0 accuracy · 2 graded-50.0

Bryant McFadden25 accuracy · 1 graded-50.0

Adam Rank0 accuracy · 1 graded-50.0

The Herd with Colin Cowherd (podcast)

65.0 · 16 graded

The Rich Eisen Show (podcast)52.8 · 8 graded

Around the NFL (podcast)52.1 · 12 graded

Move the Sticks (podcast)51.8 · 20 graded

Nightcap (podcast)46.1 · 8 graded

The Dan Patrick Show (podcast)30.9 · 5 graded

First Things First (podcast)0.0 · 1 graded

The Colin Cowherd Podcast (podcast)20.0 · 3 graded

PendingGordon McGuinnessTop Player Lists

Welcome to the weekly edition of PFF's Quarterback Rankings... 1. Josh Allen, Buffalo Bills ... 32. Deshaun Watson, Cleveland Browns

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 16, 2026

PendingGordon McGuinnessTop Player Lists

Welcome to the weekly edition of PFF's wide receiver rankings... 1. Puka Nacua ... 32. Calvin Ridley, Tennessee Titans

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 16, 2026

PendingHenry McKennaTop Player Lists

FOX Sports' Henry McKenna dropped his QB stock-market list ahead of Week 2... Young started as well as he could have, so he slots in at No. 10 in McKenna's QB stock market. ... Young ranked ahead of established QBs like Patrick Mahomes, Jalen Hurts, Dak Prescott, and even reigning NFL MVP Matthew Stafford.

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 16, 2026the article →

PendingGarrett PodellTop Player Lists

Enjoy our Week 2 edition of the 2026 Quarterback Power Rankings: NFL QB Power Rankings — 1 Josh Allen ... 32 Cooper Rush

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 16, 2026the article →

PendingNick WrightTop Player Lists

Here's how he views the league's top quarterbacks in the latest edition of Mahomes Mountain: ... 1st Row: Trevor Lawrence, Jaguars

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 16, 2026the article →

PendingLane MillsTop Player Lists

So now that Week 1 is through, we can officially form power rankings around Tennessee's firsrt-year guys. 1. Anthony Hill Jr. ... 2. Carnell Tate ... 3. Fernando Carmona ... 4. Keldric Faulk ... N/A: Nick Singleton

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 15, 2026the article →

PendingHenry McKennaTop Player Lists

#32 Deshaun Watson ... #1 Josh Allen — QB Stock Market Week 2 rankings

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 15, 2026the article →

PendingRob RangTop Player Lists

These four prospects are ranked in the order in which I would currently select them if I were building an NFL roster.

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 13, 2026the article →

PendingDane BruglerTop Player Lists

He's the top receiver in the upcoming draft class and even ranked first overall on Dane Brugler's preseason top 50.

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 12, 2026the article →

PendingCharlie CampbellTop Player Lists

The top 2027 Wide Receiver prospects available for the 2027 NFL Draft. 1. Jeremiah Smith*, WR, Ohio State ... 27. Anthony Evans III, WR, Mississippi State

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 11, 2026the article →

PendingRob RangTop Player Lists

That’s why I’ve tiered my 16 favorite draft-eligible quarterbacks below and will be updating this list all season long. #16 CJ Bailey ... #1 Dante Moore

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 10, 2026the article →

PendingGarrett PodellTop Player Lists

Our own Garrett Podell tried his hand at ranking all 32 starters in our Week 1 NFL QB Power Rankings ... For now, Stafford maintains his spot atop the league ... 16. Jalen Hurts, Eagles 17. Baker Mayfield, Buccaneers 18. Aaron Rodgers, Steelers 19. Daniel Jones, Colts 20. C.J. Stroud, Texans

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 10, 2026the article →

PendingCharlie CampbellTop Player Lists

The top 2027 Running Back prospects available for the 2027 NFL Draft. 1. Jadan Baugh*, RB, Florida ... 18. Richard Young, RB, Colorado

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 10, 2026the article →

PendingMike RennerTop Player Lists

Manning ranks as the No. 1 player on Mike Renner's Big Board at CBS Sports.

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 9, 2026the article →

PendingBen ArthurTop Player Lists

Here are my top 20 non-quarterback offensive skill players entering the 2026 NFL season, in descending order: 20. Kyle Juszczyk ... 1. Ja'Marr Chase

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 9, 2026

PendingGarrett PodellTop Player Lists

Enjoy our Week 1 edition of the 2026 Quarterback Power Rankings: 1 Matthew Stafford ... 32 Deshaun Watson

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 9, 2026the article →

PendingCharlie CampbellTop Player Lists

The top 2027 Tight End prospects available for the 2027 NFL Draft.

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 9, 2026the article →

PendingNick WrightTop Player Lists

Mahomes Mountain is back ahead of Week 1 of the 2026/27 NFL season, and Nick Wright lists his QB hierarchy... Off The Mountain: Geno Smith, Tua Tagovailoa, Jacoby Brissett, Deshaun Watson... 1st Row: 'The Best In the League' Patrick Mahomes

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 8, 2026the article →

PendingHenry McKennaTop Player Lists

QB Stock Market Week 1: Projecting How All 32 Starters Will Fare In 2026 — #32 Deshaun Watson ... #1 Joe Burrow

Waiting on the season to settle this.said Sep 8, 2026the article →

PendingJoe MarinoTop Player Lists

I've ranked the 21 players on the bills roster under 25 years old... Number one... Cole Bishop and Deion Walker... TJ Parker, I have at number three... 20, Javon Solomon.