Sharpe picks McMillan to win Offensive Rookie of the Year over Tyler Shough, and says Saints rookie Tyler Shough has locked down the starting quarterback job in New Orleans.

2 checkable claims from this

Each one is scored on its own against the published methodology. A pundit naming several outcomes is graded on each, not on all-or-nothing.

• Depth Chart CallsDec 29, 2025

  “since he's come back, he is not relinquished that starting spot. / Is not going to relinquish it.”

  Scored 100a naive guess scored 91.67+9.25 skill
  How this was scored

  club:

  NO

  skill:

  9.25

  player:

  Tyler Shough

  season:

  2025

  accuracy:

  100

  baseline:

  91.67

  position:

  QB

  naive slot:

  2

  actual slot:

  1

  difficulty:

  1.11

  measured by:

  passing yards

  naive basis:

  no prior season — a rookie is assumed to start behind the incumbent

  weeks in the season:

  18

  predicted slot:

  1

  weeks left when called:

  2

  Think this is wrong?

• Award PicksDec 29, 2025

  “I think mc millan's gonna get it, I really do... I think McMillan's gonna win it Rookie of the Year.”

  Scored 100a naive guess scored 0+111 skill
  How this was scored

  award:

  offensive_rookie_of_the_year

  naive:

  the naive pick was Jayden Daniels, who won it the year before

  skill:

  111

  player:

  Tetairoa McMillan

  season:

  2025

  winner:

  Tetairoa McMillan

  correct:

  true

  accuracy:

  100

  baseline:

  0

  difficulty:

  1.11

  weeks in the season:

  18

  weeks left when called:

  2

  Think this is wrong?